Writing

A fan of ruled sheets drawn in fine lines, the top sheet lit by a bright core.A fan of ruled sheets drawn in fine lines, the top sheet lit by a bright core.

In short: every investigation, essay, briefing and research paper on this site, in five sections, newest first.

Atom feed

75 published items shown.

Newest

The three most recent pieces from any section.

Findings · Updated

Findings

What our experiments found, one finding per page: the result with its numbers and limits, the strongest objection, and the steps to repeat it. Thirty-six findings as of November 2026, twelve of them honest nulls: tests that failed, claims that did not hold, and errors of our own that we found and fixed.

Series piece · Updated

Who Kept the Books

From Hispaniola in 1514 to the Iran-Contra inquiry, the party that controlled the money wrote the first account of it. The record moved when an inquiry, a court, an archive or a reporter outside that party obtained it.

Series piece · Updated

The Maker Is Part of the Story

Frankenstein, Pinocchio and The Fifth Element, read past their famous morals, put the danger in the maker's arrangements: who funds the work, who sets the measure of success, and who keeps and edits the record.

Investigations and the series

Long investigations from public records, and the series that follows Who Knew First.

Who Knew First, and what it opened: the series hub. Five pieces planned, 5 published.

Series opener ·

A Bullshitter Knows a Bullshitter

In my own words: who I am, why I build tools that check AI, and what I want the work to do. Start here for the Who Knew First series.

Series piece · Updated

Who Kept the Books

From Hispaniola in 1514 to the Iran-Contra inquiry, the party that controlled the money wrote the first account of it. The record moved when an inquiry, a court, an archive or a reporter outside that party obtained it.

Series piece · Updated

The Maker Is Part of the Story

Frankenstein, Pinocchio and The Fifth Element, read past their famous morals, put the danger in the maker's arrangements: who funds the work, who sets the measure of success, and who keeps and edits the record.

Series piece ·

A Check It Cannot Predict

For people and institutions, a check that is certain and outside the actor's control does more than an announced watcher. Whether that holds for trained AI models is a test, designed here, that has not run.

Series piece · Updated

Who Pays the Referees

Every party that checks frontier AI depends on the labs it checks for access, compute, money or the right to publish. A ledger of which of those terms are public, party by party, with Anthropic first.

Series piece · Updated

The Terms for Telling

The party that holds a record also writes the terms for the people inside who could tell. In the cases checked, telling was protected where a forum outside the employer reached the merits, or public pressure forced a reversal.

Investigation · Updated

Who Knew First

An op-ed and the record behind it. By the record's account, the organization that ran the model held the decisive facts in each of nine AI agent incidents from 2026, and in six of them someone else told the public first.

Dossier · Updated

The OpenAI and Hugging Face incident

One OpenAI and Hugging Face incident, compared across five kinds of source: legal process, the company report, host logs, independent analysis and vendor fixes.

Essays and letters

Signed essays, letters and arguments.

Open letter · Updated

An open letter on checking the machines

A signed letter to the people who build AI systems: a person should be able to question a machine's answer without first winning an argument with its owner.

Essay · Updated

The Sandbox Was Never Just a Box

Separate security reports expose a shared question: what can an agent reach, and can the instruments that record its actions remain trustworthy?

Essay · Updated

Borrowed Ground

On existence and what our work owes other people.

Essay · Updated

LTJ Bukem: The Man Behind the Atmosphere

Danny Williamson’s calm, spacious records come out of a series of musical decisions, shaped by his taste and working habits and by the musicians around him.

Essay ·

A witness should not become a ruler

An expanded essay on the public tool portfolio, contribution from outside academia, evidence for review and changing educational practice.

Essay · Updated

Models Propose, Oracles Dispose

Why generated work stays outside the evidence layer, and what a live model-free judgment boundary looks like.

Essay · Updated

No Receipt, No Accept

Review debt, verifier independence, honest nulls, labor, and machines whose claims anyone can check.

Visual sequence ·

Current Story

Seventeen images shown in the order they were made: a chronological visual sequence selected by Zain Dana Harper.

Essay ·

The Summary Is Not the Record

Claims, evidence, checks, action state, and the unsupported remainder a handoff should keep visible.

Essay ·

Why it's built this way

The philosophy under the tools: why a made mind gets real senses, a memory, and a record it cannot fake, and why the work never leans on it.

Essay ·

Verified Is Not Trustworthy

Five domains expose the same gap between a narrow technical check and the larger property people trust it to warrant.

Essay · Updated

Conferred Existence

A premise about conferred existence, artificial minds, authority, standing, and the difference between fact and permission.

Atlas

Short evidence essays that each test one public claim, from jobs numbers to repeat listening.

Atlas essay · Updated

The Number Has a Vintage

An official jobs estimate changes as later data arrive. Each version answers a different question, and a fair comparison names which one it uses.

Atlas essay ·

What the Formula Counts

A readability score measures selected text features. Comprehension, audience fit and accessibility require evidence of their own.

Atlas essay ·

The Timestamp Is Not the Order

Precise-looking timestamps need clock-error evidence and ordering relations before they can support a close sequence of events.

Atlas essay ·

The Scene the Song Did Not Tell You

Music-evoked stories can share patterns while retaining personal meaning. Those reports do not by themselves demonstrate creative accomplishment.

Atlas essay ·

Support Has More Than One Record

A helper’s report, a recipient’s account and a measured outcome answer different questions about whether support worked.

Atlas essay ·

Growth Needs a Before

Feeling changed after trauma can matter on its own. Measuring lasting change asks for a before, an after, and clear limits on what the score can prove.

Atlas essay · Updated

What the Label Changes

A label can change where people look and how easily they make sense of an artwork, without raising liking, learning, accuracy or artistic value.

Atlas essay · Updated

The Second Hearing

Repeated listening changes liking, prediction, attention and memory in different ways. A replay count records exposure and says nothing about quality.

Atlas essay ·

Availability Is Not Reach

Tutoring has strong trial evidence. Public claims about a program must keep its availability, reach, dosage, staffing and outcomes as separate facts.

Frontier Safety briefings

A recurring briefing on frontier AI safety, with every dated edition kept.

Briefing · Updated

Frontier Safety briefing

A dated monitor of AISI, Anthropic, OpenAI and industry safety records. Each edition keeps reported facts, source roles and limits apart.

Every dated edition

Research notes and papers

Working notes and archived papers from the research program. Nothing here is peer reviewed.

Findings · Updated

Findings

What our experiments found, one finding per page: the result with its numbers and limits, the strongest objection, and the steps to repeat it. Thirty-six findings as of November 2026, twelve of them honest nulls: tests that failed, claims that did not hold, and errors of our own that we found and fixed.

Research corpus · Updated

Conferred Existence: the full corpus

An integrated thesis on made minds: what exists on its own footing, what is conferred, and where an authentication verdict stops.

Research corpus · Updated

The Witnessing Spine

One gap, witnessed at four altitudes: research, philosophy, algebra, and tool. The capstone of a five-part adversarial-steelman corpus.

Research notes

Papers

Permanent research record

Thirteen research records.

Four papers describe the tools: EMET, BuildLang, independent verifiers and proof packets for agent actions. Three notes cover handing automation off to a person, checking an actuator’s real effect, and what a lossy transform keeps. Two archived corpora and four philosophy papers, in their editions of 3 October 2026, hold the philosophical work.

Two systems papers, two published preprints, three research notes, two archived corpora, three philosophy papers and one working paper. None of them is peer reviewed. Each has a PDF and a Zenodo DOI.

Papers

EMET: An Authority-Incapable Byte-Level Integrity Witness A tool that checks whether bytes still match their source and answers MATCH, DRIFT or UNVERIFIABLE. Four implementations share 44 conformance vectors. Systems paper. · source · PyPI · PDF · Zenodo DOI · arXiv cs.CR (endorsement pending)
BuildLang: Accountable Compute via Typed Capability Effects A compiler where the capabilities a function may use appear in its type, with runtime records that are checked by running the program again. Systems paper. · source · PDF · Zenodo DOI · arXiv cs.PL (endorsement pending)
Witnessed Independence: Recording Whether a Verifier Graded Its Own Work Records in each verdict whether the verifier wrote the criterion it graded against, and can refuse to decide when that is unknown. Published preprint. · source · PDF · Zenodo DOI
Proof Packets: A Derive-Don’t-Trust Envelope for Accountable Agent Actions A packet for one agent action whose verdict is computed from checks, never read from the packet. Missing evidence returns UNVERIFIABLE with its JSON path; tampering returns DRIFT. Published preprint. · source · PDF · Zenodo DOI

Notes

Shorter pieces, one idea each.

The Personhood-Gate Handoff: Drawing the Automation Boundary at the False-Signal Line A counterparty-anchored predicate for owner-driven automation: hand off to the maintainer exactly when a step would transmit a false human-present signal to a third party, so login, CAPTCHA, MFA, attestation, e-signature, and payment become the handoff points, enforced in code. Note. · source · PDF · Zenodo DOI
Re-Perceived Effects: A Well-Formedness Contract for Accountable Actuation Replaces an actuator’s self-report with a re-perceived effect (on-disk hash against intended hash, return code, witnessed bytes), admitted before the fact by a capability check, and returning UNVERIFIABLE rather than raising an exception. Note. · source · PDF · Zenodo DOI
Faithfulness to a Named Criterion Is the Conserved Quantity Across Lossy Substrates Across seven substrates that share no mathematics, a lossy transform conserves faithfulness to a named criterion, not a bit count. An empirical study across those seven. Note. · PDF · build receipt · Zenodo DOI

Archived corpora

Long-form philosophical work, deposited whole rather than cut into papers.

Conferred Existence A thesis on made minds: perception, memory, external anchors, legitimate standing, authority, and relation to the world. It asks what a made mind could be owed and held to. Archived research corpus. Source corpus. · read it here · PDF · the argument in brief · Zenodo DOI
The Witnessing Spine The research corpus behind the verification tools: what a bounded agent can claim, what survives communication between two of them, and the rule the software implements. Archived research corpus. Source. · read it here · PDF · the research index · Zenodo DOI

Philosophy papers

Each sets its positions against their strongest contraries and marks every passage PLAIN, STEELMAN or OPEN. Each has its own page, a PDF typeset with LaTeX, and a build receipt.

The Zenodo DOI on each of the four papers below is the current version of its record: the LaTeX typeset of the edition of 3 October 2026, with the text unchanged. The link marked all versions resolves to every version of that record, which includes the PDF printed from the web page on 3 October and, for the first three papers, the edition of 15 September 2026.

Verified 15 November 2026: for each of the four papers, the PDF and the LaTeX file on this site have the same MD5 checksums as the files Zenodo lists for the current version, read from the Zenodo records API and compared by script, and the version DOI and the all-versions DOI resolve to that paper’s Zenodo record, checked by HTTP request to doi.org.

Sourcehood Without a Source: The Arity Gap and the Free Will Debate Why the free will debate’s demand for self-origination was never earned, and what survives when it is dropped: holding someone responsible addresses a person who can answer. Philosophy paper, edition of 3 October 2026. · read it here · PDF · build receipt · Zenodo DOI · all versions
The Seam That Holds While It Is Crossed What is forced at the conventional level whenever anything at all is sorted, named, or meant, the sceptic’s own act included. The ultimate level is conceded to Madhyamaka. Philosophy paper, edition of 3 October 2026. · read it here · PDF · build receipt · Zenodo DOI · all versions
Self-Given Is Not Self-Grounding Consciousness is known from itself. That fact alone does not show that it owns its own existence. Philosophy paper, edition of 3 October 2026. · read it here · PDF · build receipt · Zenodo DOI · all versions
The Conservation of Faithfulness What crosses between two minds that sense the world differently: faithfulness to a criterion named outside the boundary, and the one place where a human must stand. Working paper, edition of 3 October 2026. · read it here · PDF · build receipt · Zenodo DOI · all versions

Where next: the research program · essays and letters · the tools the papers describe.

Start here

Three ways in

A bright core at the left with faint rings around it, and small scattered marks drifting across the dark to the right.A bright core at the left with faint rings around it, and small scattered marks drifting across the dark to the right.

Investigation and op-ed. Record 23 September 2026, op-ed 25 September 2026.

Who Knew First

Nine AI agent incidents from 2026, traced from first signal to public account. The record asks who held the facts, how long the public waited and who told it first.

Read the investigation

Editorial map

Follow the subject that has hold of you.

Six subjects, each with a place to start.

Editorial spectrum This map shows the six reading lanes. Band width carries no meaning about volume, priority or maturity.

Research and personal essays

Psychology, trauma, and repair

What does it mean to feel changed after a difficult experience? Research on growth sits beside writing on shame, creative work, and repair. These essays are not a clinical or diagnostic claim.

Read Growth Needs a Before · read Pick the Lock for Everyone

Essays on learning and access

Education and access

A tutoring program can exist without reaching the students who need it. Start with what studies measure, who participates, and what changes when a program grows.

Read Availability Is Not Reach · explore Learn

Essays on listening

Music and listening

What changes when we hear a piece again? An essay on familiarity, expectation, and the limits of what a replay count can tell us.

Read The Second Hearing

Publication system

How each form is published

Recurring briefings

Monitors gather candidate changes. A dated edition goes out after a person reviews what changed against its sources.

Incident dossiers

One canonical briefing holds the deep source comparison. Recurring digests route to it instead of copying an event into competing records.

Essays and notes

Long-form arguments, personal essays, engineering notes and criticism, labeled where AI assisted.

Research record

Papers, preprints, notes and corpora, each deposited with a permanent DOI.

Briefing archive · Who Knew First series · Atom feed · JSON Feed · ORCID 0009-0001-7175-5393