{
 "study": "tree-decline-r2-cedar-water",
 "run_id": "20261029T150625Z",
 "date": "2026-10-29",
 "prereg": {
  "path": "PREREG-R2.txt",
  "sha256": "c7064ebb39decd2d892e6820af67d00a502160b5fe20addb9eb4c98a005d1624",
  "anchors": [
   "sidecar",
   "lock"
  ],
  "plan_sha256": "1acea23f395c37e4b73c5cf2ad61279adaf5e64cd41c313ccb9f1f8d8d07776e",
  "locked_at": "2026-10-29T15:06:16+00:00"
 },
 "hashes": {
  "project_88444_slim.jsonl": "3e66a2e7b3c44ee5e0450f1ab8ea893c0a6561e659e0981c1987e93080aa4711",
  "project_164816_slim.jsonl": "4eeb1004b965851129934a7c3e26afb0171d0d7dccf2e493465e3579025c4fce",
  "observations-10.10.22.csv": "83a091932f2de84c37d568e998b9d6ed7a0760fdf9a2a42c0dcdc8ea7e0b6ea7",
  "observations-223649.csv": "6d309c586d5e6b65dbd41d9f8f36ef4eb75b62cd8491f9d3ab224b307b63dadc",
  "observations-9.19.21.csv": "9c693609384a7f46d6cac7ce72f8c5d0dc33c89eb2356d8e64b446ac91984dca",
  "gps plus DEM and TOPO data.csv": "fc94178f746d59d24bf4c21e871fcc7b4f399857462be6c38e392c5f9a02cc10",
  "layer0_plots.json": "cb698fb33711180bf62a18788114f10aa4f74e77eb61b61610575002432cb61d",
  "layer1_visits.json": "41651f8cc166296b69200ae5b3b36319cadae0122fc5b10f5686fddb99b4e370",
  "layer2_trees.json": "3d08fcc4a5c9d6512ca64973dc7bcae39ea8aff9acc7b2a779e769e874661eaf",
  "r2_units.py": "ea6d69d4a4b0a8544a2f0877b9018430285d194a5ee3b66a0f1487749b6691f6",
  "r2_data.py": "9b690cc88336ffc508fe0e10c427e16971890e280921f38217f51db886219685"
 },
 "analysis": {
  "n_cedar_inat": 4184,
  "n_cedar_inat_decl": 1427,
  "n_maple_inat": 349,
  "n_cedar_gsp": 1545,
  "n_maple_gsp": 3651,
  "n_cedar_gsp_stressed": 47,
  "n_maple_gsp_stressed": 380,
  "inat": {
   "hyd": {
    "n": 912,
    "n_wet": 169,
    "n_dry": 743,
    "n_decl_wet": 87,
    "n_decl_dry": 347,
    "covariates": [
     "urban",
     "suburban",
     "sitetype_missing",
     "disturb_heavy",
     "disturb_medium",
     "disturb_low",
     "disturb_missing",
     "year2021",
     "year2022"
    ],
    "decl_share_wet": 0.514792899408284,
    "decl_share_dry": 0.4670255720053836,
    "risk_diff": 0.047767327402900406,
    "adj_logor": 0.10848693492879667,
    "adj_or": 1.1145903462409765,
    "adj_ci": [
     -0.4316184565776683,
     0.5577610981778484
    ],
    "n_boot": 1000,
    "mh_logor": -0.05433682716667734,
    "n_sites": 294
   },
   "slope": {
    "n": 967,
    "n_wet": 100,
    "n_dry": 867,
    "n_decl_wet": 49,
    "n_decl_dry": 424,
    "covariates": [
     "urban",
     "suburban",
     "sitetype_missing",
     "disturb_heavy",
     "disturb_medium",
     "disturb_low",
     "disturb_missing",
     "year2021",
     "year2022"
    ],
    "decl_share_wet": 0.49,
    "decl_share_dry": 0.48904267589388695,
    "risk_diff": 0.0009573241061130444,
    "adj_logor": -0.12154777415236909,
    "adj_or": 0.885548745997555,
    "adj_ci": [
     -0.7128073479451499,
     0.4637153951034113
    ],
    "n_boot": 1000,
    "mh_logor": 0.10344033734282095,
    "n_sites": 295
   },
   "acc": {
    "n": 876,
    "n_wet": 207,
    "n_dry": 669,
    "n_decl_wet": 61,
    "n_decl_dry": 258,
    "covariates": [
     "urban",
     "suburban",
     "sitetype_missing",
     "disturb_heavy",
     "disturb_medium",
     "disturb_low",
     "disturb_missing",
     "year2021",
     "year2022",
     "year2023",
     "year2024",
     "year2025plus"
    ],
    "decl_share_wet": 0.2946859903381642,
    "decl_share_dry": 0.38565022421524664,
    "risk_diff": -0.09096423387708241,
    "adj_logor": -0.3075647393167061,
    "adj_or": 0.7352352673781878,
    "adj_ci": [
     -1.25699427822248,
     0.25595495082341646
    ],
    "n_boot": 1000,
    "mh_logor": -0.42135593914797714,
    "n_sites": 160
   },
   "hyd_elev": {
    "n": 530,
    "n_wet": 114,
    "n_dry": 416,
    "n_decl_wet": 59,
    "n_decl_dry": 207,
    "covariates": [
     "urban",
     "suburban",
     "sitetype_missing",
     "disturb_heavy",
     "disturb_medium",
     "disturb_low",
     "disturb_missing",
     "year2021",
     "elev_100m"
    ],
    "decl_share_wet": 0.5175438596491229,
    "decl_share_dry": 0.49759615384615385,
    "risk_diff": 0.019947705802969007,
    "adj_logor": -0.018928281181406558,
    "adj_or": 0.9812497337909463,
    "adj_ci": [
     -0.5357642074959604,
     0.4573547224596837
    ],
    "n_boot": 1000,
    "mh_logor": 0.14007465776371814,
    "n_sites": 206
   },
   "maple_acc": {
    "n": 108,
    "n_wet": 36,
    "n_dry": 72,
    "n_decl_wet": 16,
    "n_decl_dry": 40,
    "covariates": [
     "year2023",
     "year2024",
     "year2025plus"
    ],
    "decl_share_wet": 0.4444444444444444,
    "decl_share_dry": 0.5555555555555556,
    "risk_diff": -0.11111111111111116,
    "adj_logor": -0.6673089875631035,
    "adj_or": 0.5130874463776012,
    "adj_ci": [
     -1.53594005845561,
     0.3782097684316145
    ],
    "n_boot": 1000,
    "mh_logor": -0.27698678333503296,
    "n_sites": 22
   }
  },
  "gsp": {
   "cedar_flag": {
    "n": 1545,
    "n_wet": 318,
    "n_dry": 1227,
    "n_decl_wet": 7,
    "n_decl_dry": 40,
    "covariates": [
     "logdbh",
     "dbh_missing",
     "edge",
     "canopy_hi",
     "canopy_lo",
     "compact",
     "year2017plus"
    ],
    "decl_share_wet": 0.0220125786163522,
    "decl_share_dry": 0.032599837000814993,
    "risk_diff": -0.010587258384462794,
    "adj_logor": -0.3001893269964462,
    "adj_or": 0.7406779770694535,
    "adj_ci": [
     -1.6483066504904675,
     0.5915218150497356
    ],
    "n_boot": 1000,
    "mh_logor": -0.3761528440775405,
    "n_sites": 62
   },
   "cedar_wetsoil": {
    "n": 1545,
    "n_wet": 225,
    "n_dry": 1320,
    "n_decl_wet": 9,
    "n_decl_dry": 38,
    "covariates": [
     "logdbh",
     "dbh_missing",
     "edge",
     "canopy_hi",
     "canopy_lo",
     "compact",
     "year2017plus"
    ],
    "decl_share_wet": 0.04,
    "decl_share_dry": 0.02878787878787879,
    "risk_diff": 0.011212121212121211,
    "adj_logor": 0.35978448611881064,
    "adj_or": 1.4330205454591705,
    "adj_ci": [
     -0.6542468746913436,
     1.4427645775400673
    ],
    "n_boot": 1000,
    "mh_logor": 0.6925239791654179,
    "n_sites": 62
   },
   "maple_flag": {
    "n": 3651,
    "n_wet": 463,
    "n_dry": 3188,
    "n_decl_wet": 27,
    "n_decl_dry": 353,
    "covariates": [
     "logdbh",
     "dbh_missing",
     "edge",
     "canopy_hi",
     "canopy_lo",
     "compact",
     "year2017plus"
    ],
    "decl_share_wet": 0.058315334773218146,
    "decl_share_dry": 0.11072772898368884,
    "risk_diff": -0.05241239421047069,
    "adj_logor": -0.8757890459592075,
    "adj_or": 0.4165332261200071,
    "adj_ci": [
     -1.754564941729612,
     -0.13168069156727474
    ],
    "n_boot": 1000,
    "mh_logor": -1.0775383725813474,
    "n_sites": 73
   },
   "maple_wetsoil": {
    "n": 3651,
    "n_wet": 198,
    "n_dry": 3453,
    "n_decl_wet": 19,
    "n_decl_dry": 361,
    "covariates": [
     "logdbh",
     "dbh_missing",
     "edge",
     "canopy_hi",
     "canopy_lo",
     "compact",
     "year2017plus"
    ],
    "decl_share_wet": 0.09595959595959595,
    "decl_share_dry": 0.10454677092383435,
    "risk_diff": -0.0085871749642384,
    "adj_logor": -0.1712062835756629,
    "adj_or": 0.8426477311548222,
    "adj_ci": [
     -1.5335606226600615,
     0.6932047431826371
    ],
    "n_boot": 1000,
    "mh_logor": 0.010172629409358775,
    "n_sites": 73
   }
  },
  "over": {
   "hyd_share_wet_all": 0.18530701754385964,
   "hyd_share_wet_decl": 0.20046082949308755,
   "hyd_share_wet_healthy": 0.17154811715481172,
   "hyd_fill_decl": 0.6450276243093923,
   "hyd_fill_healthy": 0.5218718209562564,
   "hyd_fill_absdiff": 0.12315580335313592,
   "hyd_n_decl_known": 434,
   "acc_share_wet_all": 0.2363013698630137,
   "acc_share_wet_decl": 0.19122257053291536,
   "acc_share_wet_healthy": 0.2621184919210054,
   "acc_fill_decl": 0.2235459004905396,
   "acc_fill_healthy": 0.20203119332607908,
   "acc_fill_absdiff": 0.021514707164460523,
   "acc_n_decl_known": 319,
   "gsp_cedar_share_on_water_plots": 0.2058252427184466,
   "gsp_maple_share_on_water_plots": 0.126814571350315,
   "gsp_cedar_share_blank_features": 0.3766990291262136
  },
  "explore": {
   "symptoms_decl_wet": {
    "thinning canopy": 25,
    "browning canopy": 7,
    "old dead top (needles already gone)": 21,
    "branch dieback or 'flagging'": 7,
    "new dead top (red or brown needles still attached)": 5,
    "yellowing canopy": 5,
    "tree is dead": 12,
    "multiple symptoms (please list in notes)": 5
   },
   "heat_yes_or_maybe_share_wet": 0.3225806451612903,
   "heat_n_answered_wet": 31,
   "other_factors_yes_share_wet": 0.06547619047619048,
   "other_factors_n_wet": 168,
   "symptoms_decl_dry": {
    "new dead top (red or brown needles still attached)": 33,
    "yellowing canopy": 15,
    "old dead top (needles already gone)": 71,
    "thinning canopy": 103,
    "browning canopy": 19,
    "tree is dead": 48,
    "multiple symptoms (please list in notes)": 14,
    "branch dieback or 'flagging'": 44
   },
   "heat_yes_or_maybe_share_dry": 0.31906614785992216,
   "heat_n_answered_dry": 257,
   "other_factors_yes_share_dry": 0.10646900269541779,
   "other_factors_n_dry": 742
  }
 },
 "controls": {
  "C1": {
   "n": 1000,
   "usable": true,
   "mean": 0.009730870809542675,
   "q95": 0.49092894723835956,
   "q05": -0.49237195575862935,
   "p_ge": 0.5874125874125874,
   "compare": "analysis.inat.hyd.mh_logor",
   "description": "iNat cedar: health shuffled within 5 km site; null of MH log OR on site hydrology",
   "meta": {
    "strata": 294,
    "n_requested": 1000
   }
  },
  "C1b": {
   "n": 1000,
   "usable": true,
   "mean": -0.007441210754812547,
   "q95": 0.6555593311594458,
   "q05": -0.6464666987366046,
   "p_ge": 0.4565434565434565,
   "compare": "analysis.inat.slope.mh_logor",
   "description": "iNat cedar: health shuffled within site; null of MH log OR on slope position",
   "meta": {
    "strata": 295,
    "n_requested": 1000
   }
  },
  "C1c": {
   "n": 1000,
   "usable": true,
   "mean": -0.007774625394306622,
   "q95": 0.38110096731801363,
   "q05": -0.3719848897869681,
   "p_ge": 0.967032967032967,
   "compare": "analysis.inat.acc.mh_logor",
   "description": "iNat cedar: health shuffled within site; null of MH log OR on access to water",
   "meta": {
    "strata": 160,
    "n_requested": 1000
   }
  },
  "C3": {
   "n": 1000,
   "usable": true,
   "mean": -0.03993730979743997,
   "q95": 1.022620197625679,
   "q05": -1.201536719159842,
   "p_ge": 0.6823176823176823,
   "compare": "analysis.gsp.cedar_flag.mh_logor",
   "description": "GSP cedar: health shuffled within park; null of MH log OR on water flag",
   "meta": {
    "strata": 62,
    "n_requested": 1000
   }
  },
  "C2a": {
   "n": 1000,
   "usable": true,
   "mean": -0.8956701551606452,
   "q95": -0.2482142206970994,
   "q05": -1.6028509447945418,
   "p_ge": 0.07392607392607392,
   "compare": "analysis.gsp.cedar_flag.adj_logor",
   "description": "GSP maple: plot bootstrap of adjusted log OR on water flag",
   "meta": {
    "what": "GSP maple adj log OR, plot bootstrap"
   }
  },
  "C2b": {
   "n": 1000,
   "usable": true,
   "mean": -0.6241959696661505,
   "q95": 0.16968348647862522,
   "q05": -1.326601538128467,
   "p_ge": 0.23276723276723277,
   "compare": "analysis.inat.acc.adj_logor",
   "description": "iNat maple: site bootstrap of adjusted log OR on access to water",
   "meta": {
    "what": "iNat maple adj log OR, site bootstrap"
   }
  },
  "C4": {
   "n": 1000,
   "usable": true,
   "mean": 0.185463133640553,
   "q95": 0.2073732718894009,
   "q05": 0.16359447004608296,
   "p_ge": 0.14085914085914086,
   "compare": "analysis.over.hyd_share_wet_decl",
   "description": "wet share among random draws from all cedar observations, size of the declining set"
  }
 },
 "timing_s": {
  "analysis": 13.03547050000634,
  "C1": 17.741695100005018,
  "C1b": 15.449089500005357,
  "C1c": 8.453820700000506,
  "C3": 5.02344770001946,
  "C2a": 0.000902600004337728,
  "C2b": 0.0007330999942496419,
  "C4": 0.031917300017084926
 },
 "verdicts": {
  "AUTHOR_hyd": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.hyd.adj_ci.0 > 0",
     "left": -0.4316184565776683,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.hyd.mh_logor > controls.C1.q95",
     "left": -0.05433682716667734,
     "right": 0.49092894723835956,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.hyd.n_decl_wet >= 20",
     "left": 87,
     "right": 20,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "DROUGHT_hyd": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.hyd.adj_ci.1 < 0",
     "left": 0.5577610981778484,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.hyd.mh_logor < controls.C1.q05",
     "left": -0.05433682716667734,
     "right": -0.49237195575862935,
     "holds": false
    }
   ]
  },
  "AUTHOR_slope": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.slope.adj_ci.0 > 0",
     "left": -0.7128073479451499,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.slope.mh_logor > controls.C1b.q95",
     "left": 0.10344033734282095,
     "right": 0.6555593311594458,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.slope.n_decl_wet >= 20",
     "left": 49,
     "right": 20,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "DROUGHT_slope": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.slope.adj_ci.1 < 0",
     "left": 0.4637153951034113,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.slope.mh_logor < controls.C1b.q05",
     "left": 0.10344033734282095,
     "right": -0.6464666987366046,
     "holds": false
    }
   ]
  },
  "AUTHOR_acc": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.acc.adj_ci.0 > 0",
     "left": -1.25699427822248,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.acc.mh_logor > controls.C1c.q95",
     "left": -0.42135593914797714,
     "right": 0.38110096731801363,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.acc.n_decl_wet >= 20",
     "left": 61,
     "right": 20,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "DROUGHT_acc": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.acc.adj_ci.1 < 0",
     "left": 0.25595495082341646,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.acc.mh_logor < controls.C1c.q05",
     "left": -0.42135593914797714,
     "right": -0.3719848897869681,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "AUTHOR_gsp": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gsp.cedar_flag.adj_ci.0 > 0",
     "left": -1.6483066504904675,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gsp.cedar_flag.mh_logor > controls.C3.q95",
     "left": -0.3761528440775405,
     "right": 1.022620197625679,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gsp.cedar_flag.n_decl_wet >= 10",
     "left": 7,
     "right": 10,
     "holds": false
    }
   ]
  },
  "DROUGHT_gsp": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gsp.cedar_flag.adj_ci.1 < 0",
     "left": 0.5915218150497356,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": false
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gsp.cedar_flag.mh_logor < controls.C3.q05",
     "left": -0.3761528440775405,
     "right": -1.201536719159842,
     "holds": false
    }
   ]
  },
  "SPECIFIC_gsp": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gsp.cedar_flag.adj_logor > controls.C2a.q95",
     "left": -0.3001893269964462,
     "right": -0.2482142206970994,
     "holds": false
    }
   ]
  },
  "SPECIFIC_acc": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.inat.acc.adj_logor > controls.C2b.q95",
     "left": -0.3075647393167061,
     "right": 0.16968348647862522,
     "holds": false
    }
   ]
  },
  "S_FILL_hyd": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.over.hyd_fill_absdiff < 0.05",
     "left": 0.12315580335313592,
     "right": 0.05,
     "holds": false
    }
   ]
  },
  "S_FILL_acc": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.over.acc_fill_absdiff < 0.05",
     "left": 0.021514707164460523,
     "right": 0.05,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  }
 },
 "reproduce": null,
 "status": "scored"
}
