{
 "study": "o4b-optim",
 "run_id": "20261031T085324Z",
 "date": "2026-10-31",
 "prereg": {
  "path": "PREREG.txt",
  "sha256": "dbf3b21010c50808e984aa422ad15639f3fd93af28409e44eb4ca34c8cc53a54",
  "anchors": [
   "sidecar",
   "lock"
  ],
  "plan_sha256": "234b69bfb9702c86b356344553e6e8de24169a843d994fdac870bbc0575bef39",
  "locked_at": "2026-10-31T08:53:00+00:00"
 },
 "hashes": {
  "units.py": "4d84c04e68709f3bf77e3fea7c713681b569b08a7308979fb9bc403b25b7f798"
 },
 "analysis": {
  "nfl_distinct_kw_p": 0.736771542243082,
  "nfl_distinct_cells": {
   "random": 5000.0,
   "lbfgs": 455.0,
   "de": 4979.5,
   "cmaes": 4994.5,
   "sma": 4935.0,
   "gwo": 4618.5,
   "pso": 4968.5,
   "abc": 4005.0,
   "acor": 5000.0,
   "iwo": 2869.5
  },
  "plain_no_random_rank": 3.976190476190476,
  "gap_plain_nr_minus_bio": 1.5595238095238098,
  "cma_rank": 2.0,
  "pso_rank": 4.571428571428571,
  "rank_shifted": {
   "random": 9.857142857142858,
   "lbfgs": 4.571428571428571,
   "de": 5.357142857142857,
   "cmaes": 2.0,
   "sma": 6.357142857142857,
   "gwo": 8.857142857142858,
   "pso": 4.571428571428571,
   "abc": 5.857142857142857,
   "acor": 3.142857142857143,
   "iwo": 4.428571428571429
  },
  "rank_unshifted": {
   "random": 9.714285714285714,
   "lbfgs": 5.928571428571429,
   "de": 7.714285714285714,
   "cmaes": 3.5714285714285716,
   "sma": 2.0714285714285716,
   "gwo": 2.4285714285714284,
   "pso": 5.5,
   "abc": 5.857142857142857,
   "acor": 4.357142857142857,
   "iwo": 7.857142857142857
  },
  "plain_mean_rank": 5.446428571428571,
  "bio_mean_rank": 5.535714285714286,
  "best_bio": "acor",
  "best_bio_rank": 3.142857142857143,
  "best_plain_rank": 2.0,
  "bio_wins_per_function": {
   "sma": "1",
   "gwo": "0",
   "pso": "1",
   "abc": "0",
   "acor": "1",
   "iwo": "1"
  },
  "bio_wins_max": "1",
  "shift_penalty_log10": {
   "random": 0.022878485893261136,
   "lbfgs": 0.054357132931109,
   "de": 0.08424046573825084,
   "cmaes": 0.0,
   "sma": 12.06268269852723,
   "gwo": 13.56360483708509,
   "pso": 0.4225905072530054,
   "abc": 0.6962897477933606,
   "acor": 0.0005781972175127326,
   "iwo": 0.0658530730686522
  },
  "sma_penalty": 12.06268269852723,
  "gwo_penalty": 13.56360483708509,
  "cmaes_penalty": 0.0,
  "de_penalty": 0.08424046573825084,
  "planted": {
   "cmaes_sphere": 1.556420633748381e-15,
   "cheat_unshifted_sphere": 7.168552107919829e-07,
   "cheat_shifted_sphere_log10": 4.269013735927148
  },
  "median_shifted": {
   "sphere": {
    "random": 4408.272579895987,
    "lbfgs": 8.265610525024286e-17,
    "de": 1.1551035982257149e-05,
    "cmaes": 1.556420633748381e-15,
    "sma": 0.0001177805629907494,
    "gwo": 161.51056301970047,
    "pso": 3.130431306769816e-23,
    "abc": 3.911842849052382e-12,
    "acor": 0.0,
    "iwo": 1.1077693860649053e-06
   },
   "ellipsoid": {
    "random": 22194278.777694672,
    "lbfgs": 3.283401161577803e-07,
    "de": 1610.4580979987575,
    "cmaes": 2.3822697588341898e-15,
    "sma": 895075.2985572105,
    "gwo": 3483253.3451063973,
    "pso": 570064.2950273834,
    "abc": 1474831.5746174688,
    "acor": 845854.2364949712,
    "iwo": 493267.1400630973
   },
   "rosenbrock": {
    "random": 173391873.30630344,
    "lbfgs": 1.7190905205827164e-11,
    "de": 8.312645985739971,
    "cmaes": 3.1384183649878777e-15,
    "sma": 621.7780003953376,
    "gwo": 587448.1113111943,
    "pso": 10995.372047098008,
    "abc": 9.95738029555424,
    "acor": 5.009872087625215,
    "iwo": 929.8876370523352
   },
   "rastrigin": {
    "random": 70.20299503855621,
    "lbfgs": 33.8284866689478,
    "de": 33.69248464367398,
    "cmaes": 6.964713399653041,
    "sma": 35.23011903504769,
    "gwo": 36.61043061203843,
    "pso": 16.914288857128717,
    "abc": 24.976031878544205,
    "acor": 31.0503856568469,
    "iwo": 10.944540142515319
   },
   "ackley": {
    "random": 16.396044830987538,
    "lbfgs": 17.832606401136342,
    "de": 0.0026972321217084705,
    "cmaes": 3.0597746558669314e-13,
    "sma": 1.1552678793062907,
    "gwo": 3.5866170617655695,
    "pso": 1.155148502709825,
    "abc": 1.6503220707356694,
    "acor": 4.440892098500626e-16,
    "iwo": 0.00039413509238928057
   },
   "griewank": {
    "random": 39.58641416076428,
    "lbfgs": 1.1588063841827534e-11,
    "de": 0.5388562301267104,
    "cmaes": 2.55351295663786e-15,
    "sma": 0.2360438091455137,
    "gwo": 1.87372373167882,
    "pso": 0.10328915910380809,
    "abc": 0.025356161311089753,
    "acor": 0.022185660857256484,
    "iwo": 0.08861524008556076
   },
   "schaffer": {
    "random": 9.11481380767233,
    "lbfgs": 3.0916451349719467,
    "de": 1.77064202003273,
    "cmaes": 2.799744948918426,
    "sma": 0.861731341137112,
    "gwo": 5.340595874702709,
    "pso": 0.12787454919700597,
    "abc": 3.747700502359405,
    "acor": 0.03134948763665731,
    "iwo": 1.1785115802189285
   }
  },
  "median_unshifted": {
   "sphere": {
    "random": 4427.302088801267,
    "lbfgs": 1.6936824709438505e-16,
    "de": 1.3814883304070456e-05,
    "cmaes": 1.6196804135193217e-15,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 1.1584855998925393e-88,
    "pso": 3.9029322176376034e-23,
    "abc": 2.8921519717773777e-12,
    "acor": 9.1395465720052e-59,
    "iwo": 1.1246662375718087e-06
   },
   "ellipsoid": {
    "random": 21055354.16421017,
    "lbfgs": 8.560295350508327e-09,
    "de": 0.015108540726547035,
    "cmaes": 2.141662154230765e-15,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 1.442900520465447e-85,
    "pso": 215443.4690031883,
    "abc": 1.7503134415411979e-06,
    "acor": 1.277299849418109e-55,
    "iwo": 261140.6129077888
   },
   "rosenbrock": {
    "random": 137375004.0233849,
    "lbfgs": 2.7361763248391048e-11,
    "de": 6.846976222103846,
    "cmaes": 2.1776450488152677e-15,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 4.248344766634861e-12,
    "pso": 4.950290527694316,
    "abc": 2.0038044944256397,
    "acor": 2.865254497022139,
    "iwo": 82.44160474000472
   },
   "rastrigin": {
    "random": 66.5560351000114,
    "lbfgs": 29.848701092512428,
    "de": 25.192329928710173,
    "cmaes": 6.964708361833963,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 0.0,
    "pso": 4.974795285466456,
    "abc": 2.1708608244352945e-09,
    "acor": 20.04736051276182,
    "iwo": 8.954627145821952
   },
   "ackley": {
    "random": 16.24909522010673,
    "lbfgs": 17.54624652285182,
    "de": 0.002335916946542671,
    "cmaes": 3.1663560662309465e-13,
    "sma": 4.440892098500626e-16,
    "gwo": 4.440892098500626e-16,
    "pso": 2.4482638139033952e-12,
    "abc": 6.969594861239159e-07,
    "acor": 3.9968028886505635e-15,
    "iwo": 19.773160865049828
   },
   "griewank": {
    "random": 37.000366273471805,
    "lbfgs": 9.479306228854512e-12,
    "de": 0.4437201213452233,
    "cmaes": 2.1094237467877974e-15,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 0.0,
    "pso": 0.06152149070235591,
    "abc": 0.007924266306973293,
    "acor": 0.022156143668715322,
    "iwo": 0.12551970716673166
   },
   "schaffer": {
    "random": 8.941327202377746,
    "lbfgs": 2.167033675941444,
    "de": 1.8054422772490881,
    "cmaes": 2.3659571949777103,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 0.005364481906731714,
    "pso": 0.12787454918300326,
    "abc": 4.480878644969884,
    "acor": 0.03134948789349387,
    "iwo": 1.01269993300967
   }
  },
  "nfl_median": {
   "random": 0.00010503572416726301,
   "lbfgs": 0.0022895690064363037,
   "de": 0.0001363137271890015,
   "cmaes": 9.619724009940272e-05,
   "sma": 0.00015602074570768548,
   "gwo": 0.0001732336823703878,
   "pso": 7.756776180005062e-05,
   "abc": 0.00016341824092130095,
   "acor": 0.00018381048002457734,
   "iwo": 0.00017622252934436432
  },
  "nfl_kw_p": 0.1292999580588412,
  "gap_plain_minus_bio_rank": 0.08928571428571441,
  "gap_bestplain_bestbio": 1.1428571428571428
 },
 "controls": {
  "labels": {
   "n": 2000,
   "usable": true,
   "mean": -0.01992559523809525,
   "q95": 1.1607142857142856,
   "q05": -1.22172619047619,
   "p_ge": 0.45377311344327836,
   "compare": "analysis.gap_plain_minus_bio_rank",
   "description": "method labels permuted within function"
  }
 },
 "timing_s": {
  "analysis": 1178.7488374999957,
  "labels": 0.084789999993518
 },
 "verdicts": {
  "KNOWN_CMA_SPHERE": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.planted.cmaes_sphere < 1e-08",
     "left": 1.556420633748381e-15,
     "right": 1e-08,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "KNOWN_CMA_ELLIPSOID": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.median_shifted.ellipsoid.cmaes < 1",
     "left": 2.3822697588341898e-15,
     "right": 1,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "KNOWN_CHEAT": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.planted.cheat_unshifted_sphere < 0.001",
     "left": 7.168552107919829e-07,
     "right": 0.001,
     "holds": true
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.planted.cheat_shifted_sphere_log10 > 3",
     "left": 4.269013735927148,
     "right": 3,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "NFL_TIES_RAW": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.nfl_kw_p > 0.01",
     "left": 0.1292999580588412,
     "right": 0.01,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "NFL_TIES_DISTINCT": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.nfl_distinct_kw_p > 0.01",
     "left": 0.736771542243082,
     "right": 0.01,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "PLAIN_NO_RANDOM_BEATS_BIO": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gap_plain_nr_minus_bio > 0",
     "left": 1.5595238095238098,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "BESTPLAIN_BEATS_BESTBIO": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gap_bestplain_bestbio > 0",
     "left": 1.1428571428571428,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "NO_BIO_DOMINATES": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.bio_wins_max <= 2",
     "left": "1",
     "right": 2,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "SMA_CENTRE_BIAS": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.sma_penalty > 3",
     "left": 12.06268269852723,
     "right": 3,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "GWO_CENTRE_BIAS": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gwo_penalty > 3",
     "left": 13.56360483708509,
     "right": 3,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "PLAIN_NO_BIAS": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.cmaes_penalty < 0.5",
     "left": 0.0,
     "right": 0.5,
     "holds": true
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.de_penalty < 0.5",
     "left": 0.08424046573825084,
     "right": 0.5,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  }
 },
 "reproduce": null,
 "status": "scored"
}