{
 "study": "o4-optim",
 "run_id": "20261031T083319Z",
 "date": "2026-10-31",
 "prereg": {
  "path": "PREREG.txt",
  "sha256": "43edb85abe56495fcd70d726ef7b6f224917033ac10fefbd56fa9d1f2aa559c0",
  "anchors": [
   "sidecar",
   "lock"
  ],
  "plan_sha256": "e6fab72152c93c516de1f03d02999c1bcd691360bbef5123781902484f1059ba",
  "locked_at": "2026-10-31T08:28:39+00:00"
 },
 "hashes": {
  "units.py": "c6b782bd4b6b06963750d209065c21b4e8166f56959c141da7c589912d213a50"
 },
 "analysis": {
  "rank_shifted": {
   "random": 9.857142857142858,
   "lbfgs": 3.642857142857143,
   "de": 6.428571428571429,
   "cmaes": 4.857142857142857,
   "sma": 4.857142857142857,
   "gwo": 7.214285714285714,
   "pso": 2.7857142857142856,
   "abc": 4.928571428571429,
   "acor": 4.142857142857143,
   "iwo": 6.285714285714286
  },
  "rank_unshifted": {
   "random": 9.642857142857142,
   "lbfgs": 5.642857142857143,
   "de": 7.142857142857143,
   "cmaes": 4.571428571428571,
   "sma": 1.9285714285714286,
   "gwo": 2.2857142857142856,
   "pso": 5.214285714285714,
   "abc": 5.428571428571429,
   "acor": 5.428571428571429,
   "iwo": 7.714285714285714
  },
  "plain_mean_rank": 6.196428571428572,
  "bio_mean_rank": 5.035714285714286,
  "best_bio": "pso",
  "best_bio_rank": 2.7857142857142856,
  "best_plain_rank": 3.642857142857143,
  "bio_wins_per_function": {
   "sma": "1",
   "gwo": "0",
   "pso": "2",
   "abc": "0",
   "acor": "1",
   "iwo": "0"
  },
  "bio_wins_max": "2",
  "shift_penalty_log10": {
   "random": 0.0033230730850069,
   "lbfgs": 0.04575752328515281,
   "de": 0.256283722229516,
   "cmaes": 0.4546136509543164,
   "sma": 12.062654789966553,
   "gwo": 13.491383151165445,
   "pso": 0.3012360134760782,
   "abc": 0.4642063111308101,
   "acor": 1.9191972788767941e-07,
   "iwo": 0.40771045411639417
  },
  "sma_penalty": 12.062654789966553,
  "gwo_penalty": 13.491383151165445,
  "cmaes_penalty": 0.4546136509543164,
  "de_penalty": 0.256283722229516,
  "planted": {
   "cmaes_sphere": 3.85305334524584e-15,
   "cheat_unshifted_sphere": 6.239905772447803e-07,
   "cheat_shifted_sphere_log10": 4.176853932629986
  },
  "median_shifted": {
   "sphere": {
    "random": 4360.829348515809,
    "lbfgs": 8.235556917513077e-17,
    "de": 3.150501327694588e-05,
    "cmaes": 3.85305334524584e-15,
    "sma": 0.00014089198586471832,
    "gwo": 101.5483252159417,
    "pso": 1.376731285171e-22,
    "abc": 2.3507938910718153e-12,
    "acor": 0.0,
    "iwo": 1.4423474881138065e-06
   },
   "ellipsoid": {
    "random": 19056302.432144433,
    "lbfgs": 3.013257409936929e-07,
    "de": 2438748.679776717,
    "cmaes": 13988073.046082707,
    "sma": 985260.7786958432,
    "gwo": 2341274.308309711,
    "pso": 565676.012041166,
    "abc": 1153898.6494205506,
    "acor": 5508524.740060794,
    "iwo": 6798328.6261183685
   },
   "rosenbrock": {
    "random": 241222019.92219192,
    "lbfgs": 1.2983922081117498e-11,
    "de": 11135.816740783546,
    "cmaes": 14868778.212273868,
    "sma": 119.67886075741282,
    "gwo": 163988.0461365091,
    "pso": 3184.111097721553,
    "abc": 10.877608676065051,
    "acor": 10034.242242774857,
    "iwo": 16361638.410012677
   },
   "rastrigin": {
    "random": 65.7214552169807,
    "lbfgs": 29.848701092456302,
    "de": 40.5973778362432,
    "cmaes": 25.507102407848684,
    "sma": 26.913363358396932,
    "gwo": 31.001531665095182,
    "pso": 23.17238828132235,
    "abc": 33.312024996240154,
    "acor": 35.37309988408096,
    "iwo": 25.60197896976441
   },
   "ackley": {
    "random": 16.443913233186134,
    "lbfgs": 17.874922473744032,
    "de": 0.004036751514626236,
    "cmaes": 1.1102230246251565e-14,
    "sma": 1.1551936420568834,
    "gwo": 5.624513943015472,
    "pso": 5.3010928979801974e-12,
    "abc": 2.024960525023087,
    "acor": 3.9968028886505635e-15,
    "iwo": 0.0004162932981484069
   },
   "griewank": {
    "random": 36.3231586188333,
    "lbfgs": 1.4022893957132965e-11,
    "de": 0.5472584548891128,
    "cmaes": 6.046686484850738e-10,
    "sma": 0.18110492183449756,
    "gwo": 1.0814803630951786,
    "pso": 0.1082286686084083,
    "abc": 0.014093931752621414,
    "acor": 0.02212673343287752,
    "iwo": 0.15721412181651195
   },
   "schaffer": {
    "random": 8.827575154549658,
    "lbfgs": 3.297134656115039,
    "de": 2.5540096288956775,
    "cmaes": 8.807992259090323,
    "sma": 1.012699933877407,
    "gwo": 4.951100882978769,
    "pso": 0.12787456009496548,
    "abc": 4.877659611421782,
    "acor": 0.0313495014412246,
    "iwo": 8.807670105464656
   }
  },
  "median_unshifted": {
   "sphere": {
    "random": 4174.922249707807,
    "lbfgs": 1.7286446060476722e-16,
    "de": 1.4468074921944687e-05,
    "cmaes": 1.538894813277735e-15,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 6.164180873849905e-88,
    "pso": 4.3126960923063603e-23,
    "abc": 2.1943944418596547e-12,
    "acor": 2.657892221927527e-59,
    "iwo": 1.0016194746027874e-06
   },
   "ellipsoid": {
    "random": 15946566.580311954,
    "lbfgs": 1.3265457515675096e-08,
    "de": 6.973749642565577,
    "cmaes": 215443.4690031883,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 5.132061707328871e-85,
    "pso": 46415.888336127784,
    "abc": 1.2191380881907565e-06,
    "acor": 34982.16293285911,
    "iwo": 1064621.2407578388
   },
   "rosenbrock": {
    "random": 256518618.1932124,
    "lbfgs": 2.7782393204664018e-11,
    "de": 89.64669808295628,
    "cmaes": 3.4310676438308904e-15,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 2.419342389043553e-12,
    "pso": 66.77777002951976,
    "abc": 3.7353140363107835,
    "acor": 387.02055891212353,
    "iwo": 163.56388227606817
   },
   "rastrigin": {
    "random": 66.64930534024577,
    "lbfgs": 26.863828958997047,
    "de": 22.50164462143345,
    "cmaes": 8.954626476020547,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 0.0,
    "pso": 6.964708361834058,
    "abc": 9.527010291776605e-10,
    "acor": 25.24138070900286,
    "iwo": 12.934458165222948
   },
   "ackley": {
    "random": 16.318570176607274,
    "lbfgs": 17.857757250984314,
    "de": 0.0030322792877552907,
    "cmaes": 7.549516567451064e-15,
    "sma": 4.440892098500626e-16,
    "gwo": 4.440892098500626e-16,
    "pso": 3.6775027467683685e-12,
    "abc": 1.3337336963736846e-06,
    "acor": 3.9968028886505635e-15,
    "iwo": 19.93525700042454
   },
   "griewank": {
    "random": 38.59124020381074,
    "lbfgs": 9.242162590794578e-12,
    "de": 0.42972577103699006,
    "cmaes": 2.1094237467877974e-15,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 0.0,
    "pso": 0.054088669983430426,
    "abc": 0.007459653750943485,
    "acor": 0.022141438644517453,
    "iwo": 0.061486687962761244
   },
   "schaffer": {
    "random": 8.693357048894761,
    "lbfgs": 2.38483144656689,
    "de": 2.086618101097627,
    "cmaes": 8.807670105464645,
    "sma": 0.0,
    "gwo": 0.005364481906766878,
    "pso": 0.12787454918192692,
    "abc": 3.7477300435268783,
    "acor": 0.03134948758752231,
    "iwo": 1.3596231701954278
   }
  },
  "nfl_median": {
   "random": 7.646880116149262e-05,
   "lbfgs": 0.0017189609360503781,
   "de": 0.00014446792199484442,
   "cmaes": 0.00013531628071112385,
   "sma": 8.732732389463453e-05,
   "gwo": 0.0001150867902278373,
   "pso": 5.474663342104602e-05,
   "abc": 0.00024529499944546027,
   "acor": 9.706430141677349e-05,
   "iwo": 0.00032112631030433174
  },
  "nfl_kw_p": 0.0014782596198264712,
  "gap_plain_minus_bio_rank": -1.1607142857142865,
  "gap_bestplain_bestbio": -0.8571428571428572
 },
 "controls": {
  "labels": {
   "n": 2000,
   "usable": true,
   "mean": -0.0012351190476190361,
   "q95": 1.1904761904761907,
   "q05": -1.1904761904761907,
   "p_ge": 0.9465267366316842,
   "compare": "analysis.gap_plain_minus_bio_rank",
   "description": "method labels permuted within function"
  }
 },
 "timing_s": {
  "analysis": 1049.1932612999808,
  "labels": 0.05021429999032989
 },
 "verdicts": {
  "KNOWN_CMA_SPHERE": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.planted.cmaes_sphere < 1e-08",
     "left": 3.85305334524584e-15,
     "right": 1e-08,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "KNOWN_CHEAT": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.planted.cheat_unshifted_sphere < 0.001",
     "left": 6.239905772447803e-07,
     "right": 0.001,
     "holds": true
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.planted.cheat_shifted_sphere_log10 > 3",
     "left": 4.176853932629986,
     "right": 3,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "NFL_TIES": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.nfl_kw_p > 0.01",
     "left": 0.0014782596198264712,
     "right": 0.01,
     "holds": false
    }
   ]
  },
  "PLAIN_BEATS_BIO": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gap_plain_minus_bio_rank > 0",
     "left": -1.1607142857142865,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": false
    }
   ]
  },
  "BESTPLAIN_BEATS_BESTBIO": {
   "verdict": "FAIL",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gap_bestplain_bestbio > 0",
     "left": -0.8571428571428572,
     "right": 0,
     "holds": false
    }
   ]
  },
  "NO_BIO_DOMINATES": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.bio_wins_max <= 2",
     "left": "2",
     "right": 2,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "SMA_CENTRE_BIAS": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.sma_penalty > 3",
     "left": 12.062654789966553,
     "right": 3,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "GWO_CENTRE_BIAS": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.gwo_penalty > 3",
     "left": 13.491383151165445,
     "right": 3,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  },
  "PLAIN_NO_BIAS": {
   "verdict": "PASS",
   "rules": [
    {
     "rule": "analysis.cmaes_penalty < 0.5",
     "left": 0.4546136509543164,
     "right": 0.5,
     "holds": true
    },
    {
     "rule": "analysis.de_penalty < 0.5",
     "left": 0.256283722229516,
     "right": 0.5,
     "holds": true
    }
   ]
  }
 },
 "reproduce": null,
 "status": "scored"
}