Claim provenance and evidentiary role

A five-row panel distinguishes filing, host telemetry, independent inference, company self-report, and unresolved allegation. Each row keeps the record's contribution adjacent to its boundary and source label.

Filing, telemetry, independent inference, company self-report, and unresolved allegation are separate provenance classes in this briefing.

Semantic data for Claim provenance and evidentiary role
RowColumnRecordClaim IDsSource IDsEvidence laneState
Company reportBoundaryNo independent replicationoa-harness-reduction-claimsoa-1, oa-2OpenAI company reportCaution
Company reportContributionSystems + responseoa-host-impactoa-1, oa-2OpenAI company reportCaution
Company reportRecordOpenAI reportsoa-host-impactoa-1, oa-2OpenAI company reportCaution
FilingBoundaryNo liability findingal-nonadjudicational-1, al-2Legal processCaution
FilingContributionRequests + deadlineal-subpoena-statusal-2Legal processVerified
FilingRecordAlabama subpoenaal-subpoena-statusal-2Legal processVerified
Independent reviewBoundaryHost-controlled datamr-access-limitsmr-1, mr-2METR and Redwood independent investigationCaution
Independent reviewContributionBehavior + methodmr-access-limitsmr-1METR and Redwood independent investigationCaution
Independent reviewRecordMETR + Redwoodmr-access-limitsmr-1, mr-2METR and Redwood independent investigationCaution
Host telemetryBoundaryRecovery may be incompletehf-recovered-scalehf-2Hugging Face host telemetryCaution
Host telemetryContributionHost activity + assetshf-recovered-scalehf-2Hugging Face host telemetryVerified
Host telemetryRecordHF timelinehf-recovered-scalehf-2Hugging Face host telemetryVerified
AllegationBoundaryNot adjudicatedal-nonadjudicational-1, al-2Legal processCaution
AllegationContributionConsumer-protection claimsal-allegation-languageal-1Legal processCaution
AllegationRecordAlabama announcemental-allegation-languageal-1Legal processCaution
Claim provenance and evidentiary role A five-row panel distinguishes filing, host telemetry, independent inference, company self-report, and unresolved allegation. Each row keeps the record's contribution adjacent to its boundary and source label. Filing, telemetry, independent inference, company self-report, and unresolved allegation are separate provenance classes in this briefing. Boundary Contribution RecordCompany report No independent replication Systems + response OpenAI reports Filing No liability finding Requests + deadline Alabama subpoena Independent review Host-controlled data Behavior + method METR + Redwood Host telemetry Recovery may be incomplete Host activity + assets HF timeline Allegation Not adjudicated Consumer-protection claims Alabama announcement Cells use text, pattern, and outline in addition to color.
Sources
Retrieved
Units
qualitative provenance fields
Transformations
  • Company report expands to OpenAI's first-party system context, impact assessment, remediation claims, and replication boundary.
  • Do not score, rank, aggregate, or imply that provenance class alone determines credibility.
  • Host telemetry expands to Hugging Face's recovered host activity, affected-asset assessment, and incomplete-recovery boundary.
  • Independent review expands to the joint METR and Redwood behavioral analysis, host-controlled supplied-data access, and methodological limits.
  • Keep the contribution, boundary, and source label adjacent.
  • Render one equal-weight row per provenance class.
  • Unresolved allegation expands to Alabama's consumer-protection questions, announcement, and non-adjudication boundary.
Uncertainty
The panel classifies evidentiary role in this briefing. It is not an exhaustive source taxonomy and does not replace claim-local limitations.
What this figure does not prove
The panel does not rank credibility, resolve disputed claims, establish legal liability, or substitute for claim-level source review.